Bake Me A Wish Reviews

Bake Me A Wish has an overall rating of 3.8 based on 33 reviews. Customer feedback on Bake Me A Wish is mixed: Bake Me A Wish reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide variety of cakes, easy online ordering, timely delivery, and excellent customer service, which strongly appeal to individuals celebrating special occasions, gift-givers, and dessert enthusiasts. However, Bake Me A Wish is often criticized for its higher price point, limited customization options, occasional delivery issues, and lack of local pickup.

3.8/5.0

33 reviews

5 Stars

10

4 Stars

6

3 Stars

11

2 Stars

1

1 Star

2

All Bake Me A Wish Reviews (33)
Michael_chan98
June 01, 2026
"Nice Big Cake, Totally Fine Experience"
I ordered a cake from bakemeawish.com and, the size was really good. Like, bigger than I expected, which was a nice surprise. Everyone got a decent slice, there was still some left over, and I definitely wasn’t anxiously calculating portions in my head or anything. It felt worth the money, and I’d probably order from them again for another birthday.
carlie2004
May 29, 2026
"Photo cake turned out great"
I ordered a photo cake from bakemeawish.com and it came out really nice. The picture was much clearer than I expected, and the cake was fresh and not dry at all. It was simple to order and ended up being really useful for making the celebration feel special. Everyone liked it and a few people even asked where I got it from. I’d definitely order again.
hello_bert069
May 15, 2026
"The cake was really soft and..."
The cake was really soft and not dry at all, which I liked. I’m just not completely sure about the overall quality, but taste-wise and texture-wise it was good.
hello_william479
May 04, 2026
"Pretty good, just a little sweet"
I liked it overall, but it was a bit too sweet for me. You know how some of these are like that. Still good though, and I’d probably have it again.
Wilfred.hudson
May 02, 2026
"Customer service was a bit slow"
It took a little while to get help , but they did eventually get back to me .
DARRAH
May 01, 2026
"Cake showed up intact, thankfully"
I was kind of bracing myself for the cake to arrive smashed because deliveries can be so rough sometimes, but it actually came safe. The box had solid padding and the cake was still sitting in place when I opened it. The corners of the box were a bit bent, which was annoying, but luckily nothing inside was messed up. Overall, the packaging did its job, so I’m happy with that
leon_Heefner86
April 27, 2026
"Pretty cake, but I was nervous after paying"
The cake looked really when it arrived. The colors were clean and the writing was neat, better than I expected from ordering online. I did feel a little uneasy after I paid because I wasn’t totally sure how it would turn out, but thankfully it ended up looking great. It made the table look cute and everyone noticed it right away.
KathleenBell
April 25, 2026
"Good cake, but the delivery had me stressing a bit"
I ordered a cake for my sister’s birthday and, okay, it did get there the same day, so that was good. But it arrived late, and the tracking barely updated, which made me nervous while I was waiting. The cake itself was nice, no complaints there... I just wish the delivery part had been a little smoother.
Shelly_godina95
April 21, 2026
"Nice enough gift, but the packaging didn’t wow me"
I got this as a gift, and overall it arrived in good shape. The cake was fine and the box looked decent, so no complaints there. But based on this one order, I’d say the presentation is probably more simple than fancy. The ribbon was plain, and the card felt a little cheap to me. Nothing was damaged, which I appreciated, but for the price I was expecting it to feel a bit more special. Not bad, just not amazing either.
robert_Carroll79
April 09, 2026
"Good delivery updates, even though I usually stick with another brand"
I’ll be honest, I usually stick with my usual brand for stuff like this, so I wasn’t totally sure what to expect. But they kept me posted the whole time about my delivery, which I really appreciated. It made the whole experience feel easy and stress-free.
judithmoore0481
April 09, 2026
"Tasty cake, but felt a little overpriced"
The cake was really good and the delivery showed up without any issues, so no complaints there. I just thought it was going to be a bit bigger for the price. It’s definitely a cute gift idea, but value-wise I expected more. Weirdly, I remember the box had this tiny bit of gold ribbon stuck to one corner, which made it feel fancy at least.
Derek.cone
April 08, 2026
"Checkout was smooth, minus one dumb hiccup"
Ordering was easy, honestly. Checkout didn’t take forever, which was nice, and I liked that they showed the delivery date clearly before I paid. The only annoying bit was the address page loading kinda slow, which was a little stupid, but whatever. Other than that, no real problems
MichaelSampson_36
April 07, 2026
"The message was exactly right"
I’m always a little nervous ordering a cake with a custom note because even one typo can kind of ruin the moment, but this came out exactly as I typed it. No mistakes at all, and it made the cake feel really personal.
jeanmarie_Maier95
April 06, 2026
"I had a little issue with the..."
I had a little issue with the delivery and was worried it was going to ruin the whole thing, but support handled it really quickly. The cake still turned out great and totally made my day, so I feel like that counts for a lot, right?
marjorielowe4992
April 05, 2026
"Pretty much exactly what I ordered"
The cake showed up just how I asked for it, with the right flavor and the right message on top. I always get a little nervous ordering gifts online because something usually goes weird, but this one matched the order page and arrived looking good.
The only tiny thing was that the writing on top looked a little squeezed together, but that happens with cakes all the time and it was still totally readable. Overall I was happy with it and I’d order from them again
gail1986
April 03, 2026
"Kind of wish I’d picked something else"
The cake was okay, but I was a little disappointed after buying it. It tasted fine, just not as fresh as I was hoping, and the frosting was way too sweet for me. It wasn’t terrible or anything, but for what I expected, I kind of regret choosing this one.
william1970
April 02, 2026
"Good cake, but late delivery was frustrating"
The cake itself was really good, and everyone enjoyed it, but the delivery showed up later than expected. It wasn’t a huge disaster, but for a birthday it was definitely a little stressful and annoying. Since it wasn’t exactly cheap, I was hoping the timing would be a bit more reliable...
hello_william410
April 01, 2026
"I’ve got mixed feelings about this. The..."
I’ve got mixed feelings about this. The replacement itself was okay and did what I needed it to, but the refund process took longer than I expected. It wasn’t a terrible experience, just a bit frustrating waiting around for it to be sorted.
marion.Millman
March 24, 2026
"The cake options were kind of limited. I..."
The cake options were kind of limited. I went in hoping to have a bunch of flavors and styles to pick from, but it felt basic. Come on, cake people, give us picky little dessert goblins some more choices
hello_bernice934
February 28, 2026
"I ordered a cake from Bake Me..."
I ordered a cake from Bake Me A Wish and loved how easy it was to customize everything. I could pick the message, flavors, and little details without spending a ton of time figuring it out. I think other customers would really appreciate that too, especially if they’re sending it as a gift and want it to feel more personal. Mine turned out just the way I hoped, and I was really happy with it...

View More Reviews

Have a question about Bake Me A Wish?
bakemeawish

Bake Me A Wish Reviews

Coupons & Promo Codes

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.